Protecting Your Devices: Applecare Vs. Asurion

Apple Products, Guides

iPhone are fantastic. But they’ve gotten a little expensive steadily increasing price each year. The original iPhone started at $499. Now the “budget-friendly” iPhone 11 has a starting price of $699. This is just the beginning. Getting them repaired is where your wallet will really suffer. 

The average price of a new screen is over $200 while even minor issues like replacing the lightning port cost $50 or more. So it makes sense to spend a little extra to get some protection for your investment. You have a few options, but two of the most popular are AppleCare and Asurion. 

This guide breaks down the differences between AppleCare vs. Asurion to help you decide the best choice for you. 

AppleCare Vs. Asurion

Let’s begin with a quick description of each service: 

AppleCare: Apple’s Warranty Service 

AppleCare

All new Apple products are covered by a basic level of AppleCare. Usually, this only means manufacturer issues that arise within the first year buying an Apple product. It’s really not much coverage so people opt for AppleCare Plus or AppleCare Plus Theft and Loss Protection instead. 

AppleCare Plus for iPhones extends coverage to 2 years. It also includes accidental damage among other issues. 

Finally, AppleCare Plus Theft and Loss goes further providing coverage if your phone is lost or stolen. 

AppleCare Costs and Deductible

Broken phone

AppleCare Plus starts at $149.99 with Theft/Loss for an additional $50. Apple does give the option to pay with installments for $8.33 per month over 24 months. 

You are allowed to file two claims during the 24 month coverage period. However, repairs and replacements are not free. You have to pay these deductibles: 

  • Screen Damage: $29.00
  • Other accidental damage: $99
  • Theft or Loss: starting from $199 (with Theft/Loss Plan). 
  • Malfunction: free if a manufacturing defect

Asurion iPhone Insurance

Asurion

Asurion provides full coverage for loss, theft, damage (including water damage and broken screens), and malfunction. Unlike AppleCare, you can’t purchase Asurion directly. You purchase it through your phone carrier. 

Asurion is available on AT&T, Sprint, and Verizon under their Mobile Protection Plan, Complete, and Total Mobile plans respectively. Other iPhone retailers do offer it as well including Boost Mobile and WalMart. 

Asurion Costs and Deductible

The cost of Asurion plans depends on your carrier. Sprint plans start as little as $9 per month while Verizon and AT&T start at $14 for similar coverage to AppleCare. 

Likewise, deductibles also vary according to your carrier and coverage. However, they are similar to AppleCare prices: 

  • Screen Damage: $29.00
  • Battery Replacement: $0 
  • Total Replacement: $200 

The most interesting element is the free battery replacement from Asurion. This is only something Asurion seems to offer and is a great value for older phones. Before deciding, however, check your specific phone model and carrier to see the exact prices for you’d have to pay. 

AppleCare vs. Asurion: Who Has Better Service?

Customer Service

Both Apple and Asurion offer outstanding service. With Asurion, you can easily file a claim online and receive a replacement phone within 24 hours. 

Apple offers a similar service except you can also take your iPhone to an Apple Store and get repairs onsite. This may be convenient, but Apple Store repair can take weeks so you may better just sending your phone in. Either way, you are getting parts and service directly from Apple so you know it’s the highest quality available. 

The best form of service is available through the Verizon Asurion program. You have all the above-option or a repair technician can visit your home/office to fix your iPhone on the spot. That level of convenience may be worth a few extra dollars per month to you. 

AppleCare vs. Asurion: Disadvantages

AppleCare has gotten much better over the last few years. It now covers water damage and is more affordable than it used to be. Overall, there really are no downsides to AppleCare. This is particularly true if you’ve decided to pay off your monthly through Apple financing. 

Asurion offers great coverage and you can easily wrap it into your phone service to make paying for it and using it simple. The one downside, however, is that it locks you into long term plans with your phone company. 

AppleCare now covers your no matter where you are in the world. If you lose your phone or it’s damaged, you can send it to the nearest Apple certified repair center in your region. 

This level of protection may not apply for domestic Asurion plans. Not only that, if you want to switch carriers, you’ll lose your insurance coverage. It doesn’t make sense unless you’ve received a free or discounted phone from carrier and plan on staying with them for the foreseeable future. 

The Bottom Line: AppleCare vs. Asurion

Smartphone User

Regardless of whether you choose AppleCare, Asurion, or any other insurance provider, you do need some form of coverage. Both AppleCare and Asurion are great options that make it easy for you to replace and repair your iPhone. 

Ultimately, AppleCare edges out Asurion for being cheaper per month and more flexible with coverage. Don’t wait any longer. You have 60 days within the purchase of a new iPhone to buy AppleCare. And, you can do it directly from your iPhone so be sure to enroll soon 

When you’re ready to make your next iPhone upgrade, sell your old phone to Buyback Boss. It’s simple and easy. Click here to get an instant quote to see how much your phone is worth in a few seconds. 

Learn more about iPhones, trade-in programs, and upgrades on the Buyback Boss Blog. Start out with our ultimate guide to switching phones. It has everything you need to make your smartphone transition a breeze. Check it out now!

Related Content

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 11 to 15?

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 11 to 15?

The iPhone 15 is now available in four different versions. If you have an iPhone 11, you might feel that now is the time to make the switch. Let’s discuss whether you should do it right now. About the iPhone 15 The iPhone 15 is this popular device’s fifteenth...

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 12 to 15?

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 12 to 15?

The iPhone 15s have hit the market. If you have an iPhone 12, you are now three generations behind. Is now the right time to switch? We’ll discuss that right now. About the iPhone 15 The iPhone 15 comes in four different versions, and it became available to the public...

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 13 to 15?

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 13 to 15?

The iPhone 15 has arrived. If you’re two generations behind, and you’re thinking about trading in your iPhone 13, you may not be certain that it’s worth it. We’ll compare the two phones in the following article to help you make that decision. About the iPhone 15...

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 14 to 15?

Should I Upgrade from iPhone 14 to 15?

Rejoice, all you Apple fans: the iPhone 15 has arrived. Maybe you’ve seen some commercials for it, and you’ve found them enticing. If you have an iPhone 14 at the moment, though, is it worth it to trade it in and upgrade to the new one? We’ll discuss that in the...

Get Cash For Your Used Phone
We buy used and broken phones for top dollar! Get free shipping, a 14-day price lock, and our highest price guarantee.
GET A FREE QUOTE